 |
 |
How
do we look as an investment to investors?
|
 |
 |
A:
Take on the investor's perspective: relate what you do to
your investment performance and unique investment characteristics.
|
 |
What
is our positioning as an investment in the market?
|
 |
 |
A:
Most investors manage diversified portfolios: it's important
to understand your positioning in the context of thousands
of individual equities competing for investor attention and
shareholder resources. Companies in the same industry may
or may not be relevant to investors for comparison purposes.
Your competitors for equity capital are likely to be different
than your competitors in the marketplace.
|
 |
How
do we compare to peers? What differentiates us? How do we
address our strengths and weaknesses?
|
 |
 |
A:
How you compare to peers reveals fundamental differences in
historical performance, management philosophy and investor
perceptions. Your awareness of these differences is critical
to developing a credible and compelling investment story.
|
 |
Does
our shareholder base reflect our perceptions of ourselves?
Where do perceptions converge or diverge?
|
 |
 |
A:
By comparing your company to peers and other market groups,
you know how your firm stacks up as an investment. Your shareholder
base should converge around these market-framed perceptions.
Divergences may indicate either that internal perceptions
are not credible, or that external perceptions are ill-conceived.
In other words, the market may be trying to tell you something
you don't know, or alternatively, the market might not yet
"get it." Pinpointing such divergences is critical to communicating
effectively and as a reality check on internal perceptions.
|
 |
How
has our positioning changed over time? Has our story changed
with it?
|
 |
 |
A:
Changes in your positioning are the result of both company
and market developments. It's important to remember that the
standards against which the market holds you are in a state
of flux. A powerful story leverages changes in positioning
-- your changes relative to market changes -- over time. Identifying
changes in positioning will not only help you communicate
more effectively, it will also help your firm respond to changing
market dynamics; in other words, to become a better company.
|
 |
Why
should an investor buy us?
|
 |
 |
A:
First, take the path of least resistance. The nearer your
firm's investment characteristics are to the heart of the
investor's portfolio, the more likely your success. Many stocks
are bought and sold on the basis of their fundamental investment
characteristics such as yield, safety, stability, track record,
valuation, size, etc. Sometimes, the only thing missing is
a meeting with management to inspire confidence and action.
Second, understand that your current stock price reflects
all that is "known" about your company. Therefore, knowing
that you have a limited amount of time to get your story across,
focus on what may not be well understood about your company
-- how the pieces come together to create value. Focus on
your assumptions about the future -- your model -- and why
the investor should accept your assumptions over others.
|
 |
What
are our objectives? If we achieve them, what will happen to
our stock price?
|
 |
 |
A:
Rule #2 in The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People by
Steven Covey is "Start with the end in mind." The "end" in
this case is your stock price. And even in a market characterized
by seemingly whimsical valuations, your stock price performance
is manageable. But first, your corporate objectives must be
aligned with shareholder interests. While that may sound obvious,
many senior executives continue to be compensated based on
objectives that are not tightly tied to shareholder value.
Similarly, many companies communicate objectives to investors
that are not clearly related to wealth creation, or else inhibit
management from making decisions that yield superior shareholder
returns. Your goals should also be concrete and realistic.
Concrete so that you and everyone else know when you achieve
them. Realistic so as not to set oneself up for failure. What's
realistic? Your positioning, valuation and historical performance
provide indispensable clues.
|
 |
Are
we a good value?
|
 |
 |
A:
If you think you're "undervalued" you're in good company.
Many companies believe they are undervalued because when they
score low on some market multiple such as the price-earnings
multiple. Most market multiples, however, do a poor job of
accounting for long-term growth expectations and risk -- two
critical determinants of share price. Shareholders care more
about risk and return than market multiples. Whether you have
a high multiple or a low multiple, investors are always interested
in what your company is doing to create value. If you have
a low multiple, focus on why that might be, what has to change
and when for the situation to reverse, and what the outcome
might be when the situation reverses. If you have high multiple,
you may still be a good value if your company's performance
can be enhanced or sustained beyond investor expectations.
In either case, give investors what they need to know to believe
what you believe.
|
 |
Is
a growth story credible?
|
 |
 |
A:
Sustainable growth requires sustainable -- and profitable
-- investment. A track record of growth and/or improving operating
margins are generally desirable, but may not be sufficient
to lend your growth story credibility if return on investment
is marginal or declining. In addition, you should evaluate
the consistency of your growth story with your investment
and financial policies, and address what are or what investors
may perceive to be inconsistencies. To evaluate the credibility
of your growth story, check your positioning relative to peers
and key groups: your investment characteristics, and the perceptions
of investors. If your evaluation suggests that you don't have
a growth story, don't despair. It may be easier to improve
performance than grow, and to have a positive affect on your
stock price by communicating these intentions to investors.
Growth can be a double-edged sword: unprofitable growth destroys
value. On a related note, in crafting your story do not feel
you must appeal to a particular segment of the market. Let
the economic and strategic realities of your company be your
overarching guide. Because investors are as diverse as companies,
a receptive audience exists for each well-crafted and communicated
story. Your IRagent will help you find the right audience
for you.
|
 |
Do
we have a good track record?
|
 |
 |
A:
A good track record is a function of 1) setting goals that
are consistent with wealth creation and 2) achieving them.
Companies that manage to do this typically deliver superior
shareholder returns over reasonable periods -- the ultimate
yardstick by which investors assess performance. Factors outside
of management's control, however, may influence the prices
of industry sectors or classes of stocks over extended periods.
During such times, isolating performance that is within management's
sphere of influence may enhance investors' assessment of the
job management is doing. Identifying exogenous factors also
helps investors assess whether they think the existing environment
is likely to persist or improve. Investors understand that
in the short run capital is fixed and management must play
the cards it is dealt. Of course, investors hold management
accountable for capital and strategic decisions that set the
stage for future prosperity (can you imagine a world where
they didn't?). Therefore, in the long run, management must
be prepared to achieve superior returns relative to the market,
return capital to shareholders, or bear the consequences.
|
|
 |
 |
How
do we look as an investment to investors?
|
 |
Are
there alternative reference points or analogies we can use?
|
 |
Are
we a good value? Compared to what?
|
 |
What
should our objectives be, and how do we assess our performance?
|
|
 |
 |
Big
and ugly?
|
 |
Diversified?
|
 |
Small?
No volume?
|
 |
Complicated?
|
 |
Black
eye?
|
 |
High
valuation? Recent stock price run-up?
|
|
 |
 |
Where
do I get the information I need?
|
 |
How
do I avoid spending the whole day making charts?
|